Ubuntu vs. Windows 7: and the winner is ……

Rob Butler — Fri, 19 Jun 2009 18:00:00 +0000

Not so long ago I wrote a blog post about Ubuntu vs. Windows 7. After booting extensively into both systems I can now reveal that the operating system that will be going onto my PCs will be Windows 7.

I loved the community of Ubuntu, I loved the way it was so easy to customise (like removing the space hogging bar at the top of the screen). I loved the way it just worked – and updates like a dream. What I didn’t like was the poor compatibility I kept experiencing when using Open Office – something I couldn’t cope with since I use a lot of commercially produced resources in MS Office format. I also found that many specialist programs (like my Science diagrams software, and my symbol-based word processor) didn’t work without significant effort (wine and VM machines are not what I would call ‘making the software work easily’).

The more I used Windows 7, the more I fell in love with the new interface (which I hated when I first installed it). The enhancements provide many useful time savers and productivity tools that you come to depend on.

I love the taskbar. Let me say that again. I love the taskbar. Showing only icons at the bottom was a stroke of genius. Once you get used to them, going back to XP/Vista seems like a huge step backwards. Better still is the way you can mouse over each icon and it shows you all the windows open for that application. I love the way a middle click over a preview closes it, and a middle click on an application icon opens a new instance of that application to work on. Doesn’t sound like much, but you soon come to rely on little features like this.

I love the new Windows explorer interface. Navigating between folders is quick and smooth, as the picture below shows. You can move between document libraries, downloads folder, My Computer and the network with minimal mouse movement – and all from the same window. Another small improvement but a huge time saver once you get used to using it.

All of my software has worked on Windows 7. All the specialist software that I need works without fiddling. Live Mesh does an excellent job of syncing folders between computers (the blue folders above) – and works much better than rivals I tried (Dropbox seemed to forever be syncing MS Office temp files).

I love the ability to customise the login screen (also possible in Ubuntu) and the supplied rotating desktop wallpapers are superb. The new improved Aero makes for more than just eye candy – the screen seems drab and dull if it is turned off for any reason. Other small improvements – system tray improved, love the auto screen dimming when idle. I also am impressed by the responsiveness and the fact that I get the same experience on my netbook and my much faster laptop.

Yes I know that Windows 7 is much more expensive than Ubuntu, but Mac OSX is much more expensive than Windows and it hasn’t stopped Mac users paying a premium to get an operating system that they prefer.

Ubuntu vs. Windows 7

Rob Butler — Thu, 07 May 2009 19:00:00 +0000

My netbook was running out of space and I decided to try Ubuntu out. I’d been dipping in and out of Ubuntu’s beta version on a USB drive so I gave that a try. I installed it on all my machines to give it a good run. Installation is a breeze and extremely quick compared to a Windows installation. When the installation was over all the hardware just worked – no drivers needed. A full installation took a little over 2Gb and the machines were extremely responsive. One or two applications lacked a little polish – movie editing software didn’t seem very intuitive. I use several specialist pieces of Windows software – I was impressed that I even managed to get Writing with Symbols 2000 working under wine. Unfortunately I couldn’t get all my software to run under Wine, and I had a few problems with Openoffice which cost me time sorting them out.

A new 16Gb SSD had arrived in the post so I decided to V-lite Windows 7 (trim some of the fat before installation). The installation from CD took significantly longer than Ubuntu! I also had a little accident while I was adjusting the partitions on my main laptop – I managed to trash the partitions including the recovery partition. Having backups of most of my data on USB HDD and online backups of recent made me decide to totally wipe the laptop and give Windows 7 a go on that machine too. Installation went smoothly although it took a little rooting around online to find out how to kick-start Aero for my transparent windows. I liked the built in collection of Themes from Microsoft – although this isn’t really a reason for choosing an operating system! (The customised login screen is nice but you can do that in Ubuntu too!)

I’m not sure which I prefer – Ubuntu has a lot going for it and it’s only the need for some of my specialized software which brought me back to Windows.

I decided to summarise my thoughts in a table.

	Ubuntu	Windows 7
boot up	Fastest	Still fast
Installation size	2.5Gb max plus swap partition	8Gb with no swap/hibernate
Wireless	Worked out of box	Worked out of box
Internal 3G support	Works out of box	Needs Dell’s Vista drivers and connection manager software
Proxy	Built in proxy swapper	Needs extra software running (in XP compatibility mode)
Speed	Fast and responsive	Fast and responsive
Video editing	Not very intuitive	Needs downloadable add-on from Microsoft site
Use of SSH for SSH tunnel	Gnome SSH tunnel manager in repository	Use Putty
Samba/Peer to peer Networking	Shares files and printers without issue	Shares files and printers without issue. Windows Homegroup simplifies sharing files between PCs.
Interface	Easy to navigate. Works well on any size screen	Task bar takes getting used to. Lots of window changes and mouse moves over buttons
Security	Secure Anti-virus not needed	Time will tell. Most secure version of Windows yet (?) Anti-virus software still needed (free for home users)
Office software	Open office fine for basic tasks but becomes frustrating for more complex tasks	Office is a market leader and powerful once you master the ribbon. It isn’t free but is cheap if you are a teacher! Open office is available for the PC too
Personal finance software	Couldn’t get the better packages to sync with my bank.	MS Money syncs with my bank and has the biggest feature set.
Blogging	Software a poor second to Microsoft Live Writer	The best off-line blog writing software I’ve used.
File sync software	Jungledisk Dropbox	As for Ubuntu plus MS Live Mesh – which works much better than Dropbox
Other software	I managed to get one piece working under wine. Several did not – would need a virtual machine to run (problems printing etc)	All my windows software worked fine.
Versions	Several – Desktop, server and netbook remix (other minor versions too)	Too many to list – MS is hoping to shaft netbook owners by making them pay to run more than 3 apps (is this the 1990’s again?)
Price	Free	TBA (but likely to be costly)
Updates	Most software updates automatically – easy to add repositories to make more auto-update	Microsoft software updates automatically. Other software varies
iPod support	Basic – needs some tweaking to get podcasts to update and show in correct section	Love it or hate it, iTunes works straight out of the box
Community	Small but lots of experts Many “fan boys” or die-hard fans Sense of pride using Ubuntu s/w	Divided but several large forums Lots of information about previous versions on net

I’m still not sure which I pr
efer – time using Windows 7 (I’ve only installed this weekend) will tell. Another factor which may decide for many people is the price. Ubuntu remains free of charge – Microsoft have been cagey about the pricing and version-specific limitations that will affect net books.

Leave a comment if you agree or disagree with anything I’ve said.

Fiendishlyclever » Windows 7

Ubuntu vs. Windows 7: and the winner is ……

Ubuntu vs. Windows 7