File sync programs can replace the carrying of USB flash drives. You simply install the software on your home and work computers, and then when you change a file on one computer the file is copied into the cloud and changed on the other computers that are in the sync relationship. This saves carrying an unreliable and old fashioned USB flash drive that you have to remember to back up.
A while ago I blogged that I used Windows Live Mesh (beta) for syncing files between home and work. I’d recently got fed up of the huge wait on boot up while live mesh indexed files on my hard drive and I decided to try some alternatives. These are my thoughts on the software products I tried:
|
Microsoft Live Mesh |
Dropbox |
Jungledisk |
| Included storage |
5Gb |
2Gb |
5Gb
(no free option) |
| Ability to expand storage for a monthly fee |
n/a |
50Gb $9.99
100Gb $19.99 |
$3 per month +
$0.15 per Gb (plus transfer fees for Amazon storage) |
| File conflict resolution |
yes |
yes |
basic (renames file with conflict) |
| Retain cloud backup of deleted files |
no |
30 days |
30 days |
| Online encryption (with own key) |
no |
no |
yes |
| Other software features |
remote desktop to control other PCs on same mesh account |
|
can also do cloud based backup of files (non-syncing) |
| Referral scheme to increase free space |
no |
yes |
no |
| USB version |
no |
yes |
yes |
| Access to files through a web interface |
yes |
yes |
Not for sync |
| Icon on windows explorer to show if file is synced |
no |
yes |
yes |
| Supported platforms |
Windows |
Windows, Mac, Linux |
Windows, Mac, Linux |
| History of synced files |
yes |
yes |
no |
| Website |
link |
link
(following this link gets you 250Mb bonus space) |
link |
So which did I choose? There was little difference in transfer speed and overall functionality between products. Live Mesh took an age to start up (whether from boot or resuming from hibernation) but the other two pieces of software made little noticeable difference to start up times.
At the moment I’m using Jungledisk (I’m on an old plan and only pay the storage fees, not the monthly fee) and I feel safer knowing my documents are securely encrypted in the cloud. The only catch is the lack of conflict resolution which has to be checked manually at regular intervals.
There are many cloud-based file sync products out there, and I’d be interested to hear from anyone who has tried one of the products above or one similar (e.g. sugarsync) for use by teachers.
Update: I’ve moved to Dropbox because of the relaunch of Microsoft Live Mesh (with corresponding moving goal posts), and I kept getting file conflicts in Jungledisk. I found Dropbox was extremely reliable and I’ve got my storage limit up to 6Gb with referrals. Dropbox also links with other services like PixelPipe, providing alternative ways of getting content into your Dropbox. Remember to follow my referral link to DropBox if you haven’t got an account already – you get extra storage space!